A couple of days ago, the New York Times ran a 5” x 7” photo on its front page, above the fold. The story that went with the photo began on page 8. It was about the war in Ukraine.
Specifically, the story was about the need to find enough soldiers to continue the fight against Russia. When Russia first invaded Ukraine two years ago, there was no problem finding men to join the army. Recruits lined up by the thousands. Enthusiasm was high. Expectations were patriotic and upbeat.
But things are different now. The war has reached an apparent stalemate. Nearly 70,000 Ukrainian soldiers have been killed and another 120,000 wounded. And many of the soldiers still fighting are exhausted and ready to go back home. Except they can’t go home because there aren’t enough fresh soldiers to replace them.
And so morale is low and the enthusiasm for joining the fight has evaporated. Many young men are avoiding the army or have fled to another country. The new recruits tend to be older men, not quite up to the physical demands that war imposes.
So there is talk of a draft. The army says it needs it. The civilians say they don’t like it. No one in the government is ready to take responsibility for instigating it. And so the dilemma stalks the countryside like a ghost over the battlefield.
The front-page photograph, taken by Tyler Hicks, one of the Times’ most celebrated photographers, shows two Ukrainian soldiers sitting under a lean-to, open-sided, make-shift shelter. The sky is gray. The ground wet and muddy. The field behind them flat and empty, with thin stalks of vegetation lining the edge of a kind of roadway.
And into this bleak scene wanders a small black dog. Homeless, wet, hungry, tentative, stepping through the mud, unnoticed by the two soldiers. His left leg poised above a puddle.
Neither soldier sees him, but they soon will. Do they have food to give him? Something warm to wrap around him to ward off the January cold?
It’s a minor miracle that the dog has survived this long. Pets have been left behind by the hundreds — perhaps the thousands — painfully abandoned by their owners fleeing from the front lines. Drones have brutalized the land and wiped out homes and schools and apartments and hospitals. Dead bodies lie scattered on the ground like victims of a plague.
And dogs, like this young fellow, wander through the countryside, hungry, afraid, cold and unloved. They are the leftovers of war. They once had homes. They once slept peacefully. They once thought life was good.
Now they know it isn’t. And in their disappointment and confusion, they wander through the battlefields and the empty villages, looking for the tiniest bit of food, the smallest comfort from strangers, the meanest shred of shelter.
Their lives used to be good, they think. They used to be happy. But then something happened. Something terrible.
The dogs wonder if it was their fault. Maybe they weren’t good enough. Maybe they did something bad. Maybe if they had another chance, things would go back to the way they used to be..
But wars never explain anything.
And so the black dog will always wonder what it was that went wrong and caused him to walk one day through the mud to ask one of the soldiers if he could stay with him for the night, or until the rain stops and the noise in the sky stays as quiet as a dream.